Facebook Instagram Twitter Youtube
  • News
    • Campus
    • Local
    • World
  • Arts and Entertainment
    • Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    • Music
    • Film
    • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
    • Campus Happenings
    • Community Happenings
    • Food
    • Business
    • Travel
    • Calendar
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Video
    • Globe News
    • What’s Bruin
    • Bruin Lens
    • Film
    • Music
    • Globe Shorts
  • Radio
Search
71.5 F
Salt Lake City
Wednesday, June 18, 2025
  • Newsletter Signup
  • Contests
  • About The Globe
    • Staff
    • Jobs
    • Issue PDFs
Facebook Instagram Twitter Youtube
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
The Globe The Globe
The Globe The Globe
  • News
    • Campus
    • Local
    • World
  • Arts and Entertainment
    • Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    • Music
    • Film
    • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
    • Campus Happenings
    • Community Happenings
    • Food
    • Business
    • Travel
    • Calendar
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Video
    • Globe News
    • What’s Bruin
    • Bruin Lens
    • Film
    • Music
    • Globe Shorts
  • Radio
Home Arts and Entertainment The Weekly Reel: Can comics be used as high-concept film pitches?
  • Arts and Entertainment
  • Film

The Weekly Reel: Can comics be used as high-concept film pitches?

By
Stephen Romney
-
April 25, 2013
0

"The Weekly Reel"

The release of Oblivion marks the first film released by Radical Studios, whose publishing arm develops comics “with the assumption the comic book will eventually land on the big screen,” according to founder Barry Levine in an interview with Script Magazine in 2009.  The effectiveness of this practice has yet to be seen, but for now, let’s evaluate the pros and cons.

The Pros:

The first pro, which many of you are no doubt thinking of, is the fact that comics are a visual medium. When you decide to tell your story in this medium, you’re effectively getting preproduction out of the way. Not only do you hammer out the story into a structure that has a beginning, middle and end, you also have storyboarding and production design taken care of as well.

The second biggest pro is that it allows you to see if there is an audience for the story without taking a huge financial risk, which the practice of filmmaking is almost becoming notorious for. Unless the pages were done by Michelangelo, then you’re mostly likely not going to spend millions of dollars getting a comic miniseries created, as most of the expenses of the medium are primarily printing and marketing. This means you do not have to pay the ridiculous paychecks that the Hollywood A-listers are asking for, until you know that there’s money to be made with a film adaptation.

The third major pro is that you are also given the opportunity to create a fan base, increasing the chances of success for a film adaptation. Why do you think the Harry Potter and Twilight franchises made so much money? It’s because the books created a strong, loyal fan base that was willing to fork over their hard earned dollars at the box office.

Cons:

The first con ties directly to the third pro, as a fan base isn’t always guaranteed. If your high-concept idea doesn’t resonate with comic readers, then there’s a pretty good chance that it won’t resonate with a movie-going audience. Contrary to popular belief, comic readers can tell the bad stories from the good ones. Some people make a living pointing such stories out.

The second con is that the story could end up becoming too big for the silver screen. A six issue miniseries or graphic novel is one thing, but a series that is either a really long series or even an ongoing is hard to adapt to film. This is especially true if the high concept story covers a large span of time, as some stories can either focus on the events of a single day, such as Ulysses by James Joyce, or the length of human history, such as Osamu Tezuka’s Phoenix. This kind of scale can be very intimidating to a Hollywood studio looking for a film to make.

The third con would be the potential for poor business practices and executive meddling in the various properties. This was prevalent with the company Full Fathom Five, which sought to do what Radical Studios are doing today, except with young adult fiction novels. This was the same company that gave us I Am Number Four, and was notorious for recruiting writer’s fresh out of college and having them sign contracts that didn’t even allow them to retain creative rights to their works published by the company.

On that same note, executive meddling has also led to the downfall of many potentially successful films. While some meddling is necessary, when things get out of control in an expensive business venture, there have been many horror stories where executives mandated drastic changes to a story in order to make it more “marketable.”

In the end, Radical Studios future practices and properties are hinging on the success of Oblivion. If it does well, then it will give studios the confidence to develop more of the company’s properties for the silver screen. If it tanks, then the practice would have to be revised in varying ways, such as scaling back the budgets of these adaptations in order to reduce financial risk. Only time and money will tell.

           

  • TAGS
  • Comics
  • Movie Review
  • Oblivion
  • Radical Studios
  • The Weekly Reel
Stephen Romney

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Butterflies flying around Roz the robot

Film review: ‘The Wild Robot’

Panel 1: Student 1 grabs "USA Flakes" cereal box from selection of "Asia Puffs" and "Coco Islands" and says, "This is one of my favorite brands. I can't wait to share it with you!" Panel 2: Student 2, wearing tank top, says "That good huh?" Student 1, wearing t-shirt, pours "USA Flakes" cereal into bowls and says, "Oh yeah!" Student 2 replies, "Can't wait to try it, thanks for sharing man." Panel 3: Student 1 says, "Any time! Now let's dig in!" as both students begin to eat cereal. Panel 4: Student 2 makes a strained face, saying "URK!" Panel 5: Student 1, smiling, says "Best in the world right?" as Student 2 makes a "Bleh!" sound while spitting cereal back into bowl. Panel 6: Student 2 looks quizzically at Student 1, who is enjoying the cereal.

Comic: Different ethnicities, different tastes

Panel 1: Student 1 and Student 2 say "Hey" to each other. Panel 2: Student 2 says, "It's been a while. How've you been?" Panel 3: Student 1 smiles in a daze, processing, while Student 2 says, "Hello?" Panel 4: Student 1 continues to smile, processing "How've you been?" Panel 5: Inside Student 1's brain, a light clicks on as miniature humanoids look up Panel 6: As the words "How've you been?" enter Student 1's brain, miniature humanoids cower inside Panel 7: The message "Brain.exe has stopped working" appears as Student 1's eyes glaze over. Student 2 says, "You good?"

Comic: Brain lag

A person, wearing a backwards baseball cap with the words "Spring term" and a shirt with the words "daylight savings" written on the right sleeve, walking while dragging a blanket with a tired person laying on the blanket. Text reads: "Welcome Back Guys! Don't Worry, We're Halfway There"

Comic: Welcome back

Panel 1: Person cowers, screaming "NO NO NO"; Panel 2: Person reaches off frame, shouting "Stay"; Panel 3: Person holds a piano over their head, shouting "BACK" at a second figure; Panel 4: Front view of the second figure, with "Midterms" written on face and "Coming soon" written on t-shirt, saying "Hey, where'd you get that piano from?"; Panel 5: Person throws the piano, smashing the "Midterms" figure.

Comic: It’s coming, again

The Globe
ABOUT US
About The Globe
Staff
Jobs
Issue PDFs
FOLLOW US
Facebook Instagram Twitter Youtube
  • About The Globe
  • Staff
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
© 2025 The Globe